The Onboarding Hall of Shame - Missing the Critical First Connection

As an EI Strategist working with organizations across industries, I've witnessed a troubling pattern in how companies welcome their new #talent.

During my seminars, training and coaching sessions, I conduct surveys asking participants to rate their #onboarding experience from 0 (Hall of Shame) to 10 (Hall of Fame). The results are consistently disappointing, with averages typically ranging from 2.4 to 4.7. For an onboarding process to make an initial positive impact on the new hire, it needs to score a minimum of 7.8.

Think about this: When does an employee feel the highest level of enthusiasm and optimism about their role? It's during those first few days and weeks.

Yet companies routinely squander this golden opportunity by reducing onboarding to a mundane checklist of desk locations, supply distribution, and IT setups.

From an emotional intelligence perspective, effective onboarding should be like filling a high-performance vehicle with premium fuel. Here's what organizations consistently get wrong:

Common Onboarding Failures:

• Focusing solely on administrative tasks

• Neglecting emotional and social integration

• Failing to establish clear expectations and goals

• Missing opportunities for early relationship building

• Overlooking anxiety and imposter syndrome

• Leaving cultural assimilation to chance

What makes this particularly frustrating is the missed opportunity to harness powerful positive emotions and mitigate common anxieties. New employees arrive eager to contribute but often struggle with:

Critical Emotional Challenges:

• Uncertainty about fitting into the team

• Pressure to prove their worth despite being hired

• Fear of appearing unknowledgeable

• Anxiety about meeting expectations

• Difficulty navigating unwritten social rules

• Isolation during the adjustment period

A well-designed onboarding process addresses both practical and emotional needs while also activating, what I call, Success Driving Forces™. It creates an environment where new employees feel valued, supported, and confident from day one. This isn't just about making people feel good – it's about accelerating their path to full productivity and engagement while mitigating failure experiences.

Consider the contrast between two new employees: Sarah, who received traditional onboarding focused on paperwork and procedures, and Michael, who experienced an emotionally intelligent onboarding process.

Six months later, Sarah is still hesitant to contribute ideas in meetings and struggles to build relationships across departments, (performance improvement plan) in the works. Michael, meanwhile, has become a valued team member, actively participating in projects and building strong connections throughout the organization.

The difference? Michael's organization understood that onboarding is about more than information transfer – it's about emotional integration and connection. They provided him with a mentor, included him in social activities, and regularly checked in on both his practical and emotional needs. (A well-established cadence of feedback.)

The cost of poor onboarding extends far beyond initial productivity loss. It can lead to increased turnover, reduced engagement, and a persistent sense of disconnection that may never be fully resolved.

Organizations must recognize that every new hire represents an opportunity to strengthen their cultural fabric and build long-term engagement.

In my experience working with companies to transform their onboarding processes, the most successful organizations view this period as a critical investment in their #future.

They understand that the emotional foundation laid during onboarding ripples throughout an employee's entire tenure. These companies create structured programs that blend practical training with emotional (empathetic) support, ensuring new hires feel both competent and connected.

Moreover, they recognize that effective onboarding isn't a one-size-fits-all process. Each new employee brings unique needs, anxieties, and expectations. By taking an emotionally intelligent approach, organizations can tailor their onboarding to address individual concerns while maintaining consistent cultural integration.

To move from the Hall of Shame to the Hall of Fame, companies need to reimagine onboarding as a critical emotional and cultural integration process. This means investing time and resources in creating experiences that address both practical and emotional needs, setting the stage for long-term success and engagement.

(c) 2025 Carlos Raposo Coaching LLC. All rights reserved.

If you’re looking for a trusted partner to enhance your organization’s leadership capacity, drive cultural transformation, or unlock your team’s potential, I welcome the opportunity to collaborate. Let’s connect and discuss how I can help you achieve your vision for success. - For more information, visit: www.carlosraposocoaching.com or contact me directly at 1-888-293-1680.

#Hiring #Recruitment #HR #Workculture #Onboarding #Recruiters #Success #Management